In these days of presidential interregnum, the American public has seen newspapers and digital media filled with discussions of tax cuts, increased military and infrastructure spending, economic growth proposals, regulatory relief, immigration reform, repealing Obamacare, reducing the national debt, keeping deficits on a short leash, draining the swamp of political and economic favoritism and other domestic traumas.
Social Security, however, has received little attention. How the new administration will accomplish all these promises without yielding to the temptation to cut programs like Social Security is an open question. President-elect Trump, who enjoyed the support of working class Americans, promised during the campaign not to cut Social Security. Speaker Paul Ryan said he has no plans to change Social Security, although he has been outspoken on the need for entitlement reform.
Funny how a politician can forget campaign promises after election day. Loyalty appears to be paramount for these folks until all of a sudden it isn’t. Politicians all too frequently forget, to put it in the cant language of the ‘hood, that a deal is a deal.
Social Security is a promise to all eligible Americans that they will not live in abject poverty if they become disabled or when they get old, but the Social Security 2015 Trust report finds that the fund has enough money to pay full benefits until 2034. After that it will collect only enough in taxes to pay 79 percent of benefits.
With the number of workers available to pay for Social Security benefits falling rapidly, there will inevitably be calls for benefit cuts, higher taxes or both. But there is a better way.
Social Securityis not an entitlement program; it is a “pay-as-you-go” system funded by the payroll tax. Companies and nearly 168 million working people pay into it to provide benefits to about 60 million retirees. Each generation pays for current retirees in return for a commitment that the next generation will do the same.
It is the backbone of retirement planning for millions of Americans. Almost a third of retirees receive practically all their retirement income from the system and about two thirds receive the majority of their retirement income from Social Security.
The top 100 CEOs, in contrast, have platinum pension plans. On average, their massive next eggs are large enough to generate about $253,000 in monthly retirement payments for the rest of their lives. Heaven for them, hell for the ordinary American worker.
Dealing with the coming Social Security funding crisis by raising the payroll tax places a significant burden on low-wage workers, especially when the Federal Reserve has kept interest rates so low that their saving accounts are yielding next to nothing, forcing baby boomers to work longer and retirees to rely even more on Social Security income.
An alternative that merits serious consideration is to increase the ceiling on annual wages subject to Social Security payroll taxes, which is currently at $118,500. All annual income above that amount is exempt from the tax, meaning that 94 percent of Americans pay Social Security tax on all their income but the wealthiest 6 percent do not.
Expanding the payroll tax to all earnings above $118,500 would wipe out funding issues. According to Social Security actuaries, it would keep the Trust solvent for the next 45 years.
Since Social Security began, the need for retirement income has risen as life expectancy has increased by 17 years. This is particularly true for top earners who need Social Security the least and whose jobs are less physically demanding than those of construction workers, janitors, etc.
Political leaders have time to decide how to address Social Security’s long-term funding problems. As they contemplate potential solutions, they should consider expanding the payroll tax to include all earnings. It’s a fair way to rescue the program from financial limbo and provide lasting stability without taking draconian measures that would harm tens of millions of hard-working Americans.
Originally Published: December 23, 2016